That isn’t to say it’s exactly like Smash, as there are some key changes to set All-Star Brawl apart. One example is in the controls. You have three attack buttons: normal, strong attack, and special attack, along with a dedicated jump button (and no “press up to jump” option). Smash’s “Tilt” moves, where you move the analog stick slightly in one direction and press the normal attack button, are instead remapped to D-pad or analog stick plus normal attack button in All-Star Brawl. This is a very clever way to implement these attacks while reducing the odds of a wrong input, and as someone who frequently overshoots the tilt threshold in Smash, I greatly appreciated it. Also welcome is a dedicated “strafe” button to keep a character facing a specific direction while moving around the arenas. Advanced mechanics familiar to Smash faithful, like wavedashing, perfect guarding, and attack priority, have been deliberately emphasized and expanded upon.

Players who want to dig deep into the game systems and compete with others will find a lot here to enhance their experience. The training mode has some unique and interesting features, including a full hitbox viewer–an extremely useful tool that very few fighting games include as a feature–and the ability to advance frame-by-frame to study move properties and interactions on a highly detailed level. All-Star Brawl also offers rollback netcode for online play. Rollback has become greatly preferred by competitive gaming enthusiasts over the more common delay-based netcode, so seeing it in All-Star Brawl shows a genuine commitment to that particular audience–though in my testing, it still proved to be a bit iffy through long-distance or Wi-Fi-based online connections. Overall, there’s plenty of meat to dig into here for those who want a mechanically rich platform fighter that isn’t quite a Smash game, but still close enough.

So Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl is mechanically sound, which is great. But for a game that’s trying very hard to put up a serious fight against Smash, it falls short in significant ways. The main reason Smash Bros. is such a runaway success is that the game works on numerous levels: as a competitive game, as a party game, and as a showcase for fan-service. You can play Smash with a strictly competitive ruleset, or you can turn on all of the items and play on the blatantly cruel stages to goof off. You can even ignore multiplayer altogether and sink hours into a variety of single-player content options while enjoying all the Nintendo fan-service and gaming references.

Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl, in comparison, gets the competitive element right, but everything else is severely lacking. There are no wacky, overpowered items at all, and while a couple of the stage designs do present interesting challenges and hazards, most of them feel pretty restrained, both in terms of presentation and the dangers they provide. As a single-player experience, there’s not much to chew on at all: a short arcade challenge mode, a “sports” mode (where the object is to score goals rather than launching each other), and the usual quick stock–and time-based battles against CPU fighters are all you get. You can unlock various extras like music and gallery images in these modes, but the rewards aren’t particularly interesting overall.

But the fan-service element–or lack thereof–is the most disappointing thing. Much like Smash Bros., Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl is packed with a star-studded cast of characters from the network’s huge library of shows. These characters aren’t random nobodies–they mean a lot to multiple generations of players, and having them in a crossover game like this is an exciting prospect. While developer Ludosity has done an admirable job with many of the animations and attacks, things like the lack of character voiceover during fights, no character-specific single-player stories or endings, and generic pre-fight dialogue exchanges in arcade mode are a tremendous disappointment. It’s sad that a brawl between the likes of Ren and Stimpy, Toph, Patrick Star, and Michelangelo is almost completely silent–the potential for funny character interactions there is wasted.

Ultimately, Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl is a solid competitive platform fighter, but it’s lacking in several key elements. If you’ve got a group of buddies that enjoy competitive Smash and have a lot of love for Nickelodeon’s catalog of cartoon characters, you’ll find All-Star Brawl quite satisfying. But if you’re looking for substantial single-player experiences or a fun mess-around party fighter you can play casually with friends and family, you’re going to run back to the warm embrace of Nintendo’s juggernaut very quickly.